Running with a Spoonful in Life's Gallery

Monday, July 06, 2009

Nudge - Richard Thaler and Cass R. Sunstein


A pretty good read! This book can be broadly cut into two parts. The first part explains in pretty layman terms the idea behind "libertarian paternalism", while the second part goes in depth about how this idea can be applied across a range of issues, from healthcare, saving the planet, to even marriages.

Will just touch on what the authors refer to as libertarian paternalism, and what an understanding of this issue will allow us to do about it. The line of logic goes something like this:

  1. In a perfect world, all humans are rational and can make economic decisions accurately. In such a world, free market will ensure that humans optimise their choices and any increase in the complexity (or simply, number) of choices, is beneficial to humans.
  2. However, in the real world, humans are really bad at making such rational economic choices, due to the following "interferences" - tending towards rules of thumb (anchoring, availability, representativeness, overconfidence in one's abilities, larger aversion to loss than gain, bias towards status quo, laziness, following the herd, or simply being overwhelmed by the complexity of the decision.
  3. In such a situation, the Government can step in to influence humans at moments, when they are irrational or slightly weak, towards decisions that are beneficial to them without actually forcibly removing options from the table. e.g. giving citizens a large range of healthcare plans to choose from but gently influencing them to pick a better choice. This is known as "libertarian paternalism", which at times seems pretty oxymoronic, I must admit.
  4. Such a framework that influences the behavior of the decision maker makes use of the very "interferences" that could potentially cause the human to make a wrong choice in the first place, but applies it for the good of the human. This framework is known as "choice architecture".
I think the ideas behind this book is extremely useful in policy-making, especially in areas where a mandatory option is politically unfeasible, and/or if there is clearly a "better" solution that the human should take. (The authors go through lengths to defend their point of view towards the end of the book, and I must say that they did quite a good job!) The applications towards sales and marketing is significant, as far as I can see.

Labels:

2 Comments:

  • I just attended exec training at Wharton and this book was recommended.. thanks for summarising it for me so i wont have to read it haha. But seriously, you inspire me alot Daosong.. especially in your insatiable thirst for knowledge and understanding of the world and society and yourself. I have some interesting takeaways from my Wharton experience that I would lurve to share with you and that I am sure will intrigue you. But I dont know when we will have time to catch up on our aspirational talk (at starbucks no less!!) and dont know when i will have the time and energy to sit down and put it all in an email. I will try the latter. Expect it in before 2012. haha. ;-))

    By Blogger Unknown, at 7:25 PM  

  • But to comment on the book (or at least your summary of it since I havent read it myself and am unlikely to ever read it), isn't libertarian paternalism just another term for enlightened authoritarianism or plain paternalism (since the term paternal itself means the fatherly and therefore not harmful)? These ideas dont seem too new to me leh... didnt we all learn this at Political Science 101? Just some thoughts...

    By Blogger Unknown, at 7:32 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home